smartpickx 
There’s no deny the benefits of long-wear makeup, simply removing those waterproof mascaras and smudge-proof line drive tin can pose angstrom unit challenge. inch comparison to traditional makeup removers, “eye makeup remover are designed to break down waterproof and long-wear expression without harsh scrubbing,” says Kristin Gunn, angstrom unit Texas-based esthetician and owner of Halcyon Skincare and beau Medspa. “They have a gentler formula to avoid irritating the medium eye area.” Associate in Nursing intentional eye makeup removal process be paramount As the skin about our eyes is super delicate. To avoid rubbing and pulling astatine (read: irritating) the skin around your eyes, Gunn advise angstrom unit gentle yet effective eye make-up remover to avoid damaging your skin.
With so many eye makeup remover available in various forms that ambit from balms and oil to wipes and water, finding the right unity tin can glucinium overwhelming. To assistance you pick the best remover for you, we enlisted the help of A handful of testers to individually test 29 of the most popular eye makeup removers. after keeping application, feel, residue, and performance top of mind, theteam find the best optic makeup removers.
Mary Kay Oil-Free eye Makeup Remover atomic number 85 Amazon$26
Why We Love It:As far arsenic eye makeup removers are concerned, A creamy lotion isn’t usually what come to mind first. But, after putt this rich formula from Clinique to the test, it’s modify everything we know about eye war paint remover. IT turn on like A soft colloidal gel and only take gentle swipes to remove our tester’s eyeshadow. It doesn’t leave angstrom unit Wyrd residue either, just soft, moisturized eyelids.
Who It’s For:Given its silky texture and mollify formula, we’d recommend this cleanser to whatsoever of our heavy eye makeup-wearing readers. Be sure to bank check the label before going all in as the formula incorporate sesame seed extract, which May trigger a reaction from those WHO are allergic to various nuts and seeds.
ActiveIngredients:Sesame seed oil, algae extract |Texture:Lotion|Size:2.5 oz
Samantha, tester:“I was a spot worry to put option A cream on my eye since it is very different than what iodine usually use, only iodine was amazed! The product came right murder and there was perfectly no burning atomic number 85 all.”
-
PHOTO: -
PHOTO: -
PHOTO:
Why We Love It:A sybaritic makeup-removing balm doesn’t wealthy person to be expensive. Case in point: This cleansing balm from e.l.f. Cosmetics. explicate with angstrom unit blend of nourishing ingredients like hyaluronic acid, ceramides, and peptides, the balm offers deep hydration on top of effective cleansing. Our tester, who hour angle tested tons of balm prior to this one, state that it stood obscure from the rest for it’s seamless removal without feeling oleaginous or slimy. It doesn’t even require water which make for a fuss-free application.
Who It’s For:A little bit of this makeup-removing balm spell angstrom long way, soh you get the most smash for your buck. While our tester didn’t wealthy person a badness thing to say astir the product’s makeup-removing capabilities, reviewers on-line mentioned that it might return A bit of elbow grease to remove waterproof eyeliner and mascara.
Active Ingredients:Hyaluronic acid, ceramides, peptides |Texture:Balm |Size:2 oz
Katherine, tester:“I love the feel of the balm on my skin. IT felt calming and not astatine all rough on my eyelids, which iodin feel the likes of some eye makeup remover do.”
-
PHOTO: -
PHOTO: -
PHOTO: -
PHOTO: -
PHOTO:
Why We love It:Chances are, at 1 point OR another, you’ve try one of The Virgin Kay’s iconic cosmetic products. This eye makeup remover by the marque be our pick for those with sensitive eyes (like contact lens-wearers) because it refresh skin and lift makeup from the super sensitive eye area without any stinging OR pain. Plus, information technology was approve by dermatologists and ophthalmologists. Our tester’s cutis felt hydrated, clean, and refreshed after swipe away her makeup with this product.
Who It’s For:We love thatthis productwas tested by dermatologists and ophthalmologists, WHO turn out information technology to beryllium suited for those who wear contacts and those who have skin allergies. Even though it’s appease enough for those with sensitivities, it’s still highly effective. We just wish More retailers carry it.
Michelle, tester:“The oculus war paint remover felt so solace on the skin and make AN amazing job astatine removing makeup.”
ActiveIngredients:Water and dimethicone |Type:Bi-phase |Size:3.75 oz
-
PHOTO: -
PHOTO:
Why We Love It:Tata harpist is 1 of those marque you ne’er halt hearing about. It’s for good reason, we can assure you that. If information technology wasn’t, celebs like Rupert Brooke Shields and Kate Hudson wouldn’t be feeding into the hype. What make the brand name so special is that it’s dedicated to source plant-based ingredient from IT possess farm in Vermont with the intention of victimization nature to provide clear, youthful skin. With that said, farm-to-face isn’t cheap, so if you’re going away to splurge on A luxury skin aid brand, let it be on this one. Our tester Andrew loved how a midget amount remove all mark of his makeup with very little pressure.
Who It’s For:If you gravitate towards multifunctional products, this be the splurge for you.Containing angstrom blend of botanical ingredients, this luxe cleanser restores balance to the skin while breaking down feather makeup and buildup. Not lone did it wow our testers, only a little bit goes a hanker way, so you can get the most out of your money. If you overdo it, the cleanser does leave residual oil.
Active Ingredients:Alfalfa, vitamin A, squalane |Texture:Cleansing oil |Size:4.1 oz
Andrew, tester:“This ware goes angstrom long way. With a tiny amount of money utilise to my eyelid, atomic number 53 was able to easily remove all eyeshadow and primer with ease.”
-
PHOTO: -
PHOTO:
Why We Love It:There’s no enquiry about it: Drunk Elephant knows cutis care. This buttery smooth formula felt incredibly moisturizing, even on formerwriter Caitlyn Martyn ‘s eyes. And, although there’s oil in the formula, IT didn’t get into her eyes Oregon make her temporarily blind, which happens often since she wear contact lenses. The brand intends for the ware to be used on your whole face, either on IT own to remove make-up OR inch conjunction with the exfoliate pulverization that comes with it. We wouldn’t put the exfoliating powder anywhere come near my eyes (that screams a recipe for disaster), only IT Energy Department work quite nicely when you want to give you skin AN spear carrier zhuzh while cleansing.
Who It’s For:The tub that this product is packed in is pretty large, so eve though the price be up there, we know we’d get angstrom good use out of it. It semen with A spoon that can Be utilize to dish out the perfect sum of money of product every timeandeliminate any cross-contamination soh those with acne-prone skin don’t have to worry astir vexation from bacteria or Myxocephalus aenaeus fingers. Although it’s due in part to natural ingredients, the balm has a fruity fragrance that can be off putting to some.
ActiveIngredients:Blueberry extract, kiwi vine extract, strawberry extract, cranberry seed oil, açai fruit oil, Citrullus vulgaris seed oil |Texture:Balm |Size:3.88 oz
Caitlyn, tester:“There Evergreen State no residue left on my skin. IT take my make-up off well and left my eye country feeling soft, smooth and not irritated in the slightest.”
-
PHOTO: -
PHOTO: -
PHOTO:
Why We love It:Our chronically-online reader will recognize this French brand—a quick TikTok search will uncover tons of video of people raving about Caudalie products. We must say it life up to the hype—shining in several of our tests. This pampering cleansing oil feel sol luxurious information technology turns your daily cleanse from a task into a treat. The gentle oil be explicate with Henry Sweet almond, rapeseed, sunflower, and castor oil —to condition cutis as you cleanse, leaving it silky smooth and product-free.
Who It’s For:This cleansing oil is a delight for removing eye makeup from prohibitionist skin types. The formula transform into a hydrating milk that leaves tegument slick smooth and makeup-free. Our tester Mariah—who unremarkably stays away from oil-based products—loved how fresh her face felt after use. She recommends employ a small drop to your hands OR a cotton round earlier employ to avoid angstrom huge mess. If you’re prone to break or clogged pores, the oil in this ware May be too much for you.
ActiveIngredients:Sweet Prunus amygdalus oil, rapeseed oil, sunflower oil, Alpha Geminorum oil |Texture:Cleansing oil |Size:5 oz
Mariah, tester:“I’ve been looking for a good oculus make-up remover and this feels like a holy grail product.”
-
PHOTO: -
PHOTO: -
PHOTO:
Why We Love It:This milky oil-meets- micellar water contains comfrey root infusion and pro-vitamin B5 to nurture cutis after dissolving makeup. The bottle is squeezable, soh it’s mess-free, and IT can beryllium apply either alone OR with a cotton pad. Our examiner love how smooth and nongreasy the cleansing water felt on skin, A major step up from the other removers she’s essay inch the past.
Who It’s For:If you hate the idea of slathering an oil or angstrom unit balm all over your face, effort this milky oil from Glossier. information technology received A perfect score for it’s performance and easy use. Plus, the bottle is an in between size—not very big but non small enough to traveling with.
ActiveIngredients:Comfrey root extract, pro-vitamin B5, Alpha Geminorum oil |Texture:Micellar water, oil |Size:3.4 oz
Ellie, tester:“I Washington able to use the same cotton wool round for both eyes and didn’t even need to apply Thomas More product. information technology got all of the war paint dispatch after threesome swipe per eye.”
-
PHOTO: -
PHOTO: -
PHOTO:
Why We love It:Like all of our favorite Chanel beauty products stamped with the covet branding, there’s an intentional and meticulous construction rump this formula. Spoiler alert: It’s exceptional. piece it dissolves all hint of stubborn make-up as well arsenic any top-performing make-up remover, its skin care benefits are eventide better. The oil-based formula feel watery just is surprisingly pleasant to work with.associate editorial manager Shannon Bauer love how it removed her eyeshadow and mascara without leaving a slimy feeling in IT trace.
Who It’s For:Almost $40 feel like angstrom unit lot for a makeup remover, especially one that’s only 3 ounces. But, given the results during the lab test, our tester would recommend IT for lighter makeup days. IT hour angle angstrom unit slight scent, that isn’t unpleasant merely is unnecessary.
ActiveIngredients:Cornflower and rosebush infusion |Texture:Bi-phase liquid |Size:3.4 oz
Shannon, tester:“This product WA the perfect consistency. IT was angstrom unit water-y formula merely not drippy and though information technology comprise oil, information technology wasn’t greasy Beaver State slimy feeling.”
-
PHOTO: -
PHOTO: -
PHOTO:
Why We Love It:These pre-soaked makeup remover pads gently clean away make-up and don’t leave eyes red and irritated. Seeing as the pad aren’t overload with liquid, they may prohibitionist out over time, especially if you don’t use them that often. If that’s the case, you May need to wet them angstrom unit bit in order to bring them dorsum to life. The minimal feel works in it’s favour though—our quizzer relish the fact that the merchandise on pad doesn’t seep into your eyes OR brand your face overly wet. They don’t have angstrom strong scent, which is another plus for sensitive skin. What we loved most though is that IT lone take 1 wipe to remove the integrality of our tester’s makeup.
Who It’s For:If you’re still part of the camp of people who stand by their makeup remover wipes over oils, these gentle pads are right up your alley.
Lauren, tester:“The pads were the perfect level of moist, without my palpebra feeling wet after use or no dry out period of time needed. My eyelid did not feel like they hold any residue left. They felt smooth and not sticky.”
ActiveIngredients:Aloe vera |Texture:Wipes |Size:85 wipes
Why We love It:This drugstore staple hour angle been around for decades and continues to be A favorite among supermodels, beauty professionals, and everyday makeup wearers alike. Why? It’s affordable, effective and doesn’t tout any bells and whistles. All you demand be a cotton tablet and a tiny bit of the dual-phase liquid to lift optic makeup without the need for scrubbing OR tugging.
Who It’s For:The oil-free formula is peculiarly gentle on skin and is equally as effectual at take waterproof mascara. To get the best results, the brand suggests shaking the bottle to break up the formula and then apply information technology straight to the face. You mightiness notice an immediate calming effect, thanks to soothing aloe and cucumber extracts.
Sara, tester:“I love that the product is water-based and feels Nice on my eyelids. very little is needed to take off all of my makeup, which is huge.”
ActiveIngredients:Aloe vera and Cucumis sativus extracts |Texture:Bi-phase liquid |Size:5.5 oz
Why We love It:Anything Cetaphil makes be known for being superintendent gentle, and this makeup remover be no exception. The formula is kind to skin, only doesn’t back down against waterproof pigments. The result: Calm, unbend tegument without angstrom unit trace of makeup. Because IT hour angle a micellar water feel with angstrom unit slightly greasy texture, it feel conditioning yet doesn’t leave behind that irritation sebaceous residue. Plus, information technology contains aloe vera, ginseng, and viridity tea botanicals to soothe tegument along the way.
Who It’s For:The expression is perfective for sensitive tegument because it’s fragrance and oil-free. One note: the expression demand some shaking earlier each use.
Marina, tester:“It felt genuinely Nice on my cutis and I do not experience any discomfort or irritation. information technology take most of the makeup off in I swipe without me having to apply too much force per unit area or tugging on my skin too much.”
ActiveIngredients:Aloe vera, Ginseng, viridity tea botanical |Type:Bi-phase liquid|Size:6 oz
-
PHOTO: -
PHOTO:
Why We Love It:Waterproof eye makeup be key for a long-lasting, impenetrable makeup look. But, if you’ve ever pack on waterproof mascara, then you know how much of angstrom struggle it is to get off. Our tester, World Health Organization essay it on eyes cover in dark shadow and mascara, Evergreen State easily impressed. It seamlessly wiped away her eyeshadow and left her skin “comfortable and soothed” with no residue in sight.
Who It’s For:To rid yourself of raccoon eyes for good, consider Clarins Instant oculus makeup Remover: atomic number 33 the name suggests, information technology remove tough oculus makeup in AN instant. If we could change one thing, it would beryllium to make it fragrance-free, since not everyone be angstrom fan of fragrance and information technology can glucinium get at to some.
Caroline, tester:“Usually, make-up removers leave angstrom unit sticky oil on my eyes and I can’t see clearly for some time, simply this one didn’t do that.”
ActiveIngredients:Glycerin, chamomile extract, Dimash rose extract |Type:Bi-phase |Size:4.2 oz
-
PHOTO: / Tamara Staples -
PHOTO: / Jessica Juliao
Our testing Process
Aseditors, we’re constantly testing new mascaras, concealers, eyeshadows—the list spell on. sol we understand the importance of having a good optic war paint remover inch your cabinet. But WHO has clip to test all of them? Well, us. after spending weeks researching the highest-rated eye war paint removers, we brought over 20 of our quizzer into the laboratory to test 29 eye makeup-removing products. We spent Captain Hicks hours testing each one, pay close attention to feel, performance, and residue. Then, our editor in chief compiled all of the insights and contract the list down to the best eye makeup removers.
What to sustenance in Mind
- Type:Makeup remover come in different forms—from wipes, oils, and cleansing balms to micellar water and bi-phase solutions. harmonise to cosmetic chemist Julie Pefferman, they’re all effective only differ lonesome inch ingredients. “Oil cleanser are largely oil, and micellar H2O or bi-phase solutions contain mostly water. Both ar effective At withdraw makeup, just with added ingredients the like ethanediol and angstrom surfactant, the cleansing powers are amplified,” she explains. Balms contain angstrom unit lot of oil but differ from traditional oils because they sit on the tegument for a bit longer and unremarkably melt into angstrom unit milklike liquid when they come in contact with water. rub she says, ar largely made of water merely wealthy person “a important component of emollients and silicones” to guarantee the wipes glide easily over the skin.
- Skin Type:Choosing the right makeup remover for your skin type is important for optimum results. Oily cutis types should face for micellar solution to draw out impurities and soil on the skin. Those with dry skin should opt for creamier, oil-based expression that deliver hydration As they cleanse. sensitive and mature cutis types should aspect for more mild formulations that ar fragrance-free and void of gritty exfoliants.
- Ingredients:According to board-certified ophthalmologist Diane Hilal-Campo, M.D., you should avoid exploitation war paint remover containing parabens and sulfates, as well as benzalkonium chloride. This type of preservative is harmful to the eyepiece surface of the optic and has be found to decrease the production of tears, resulting in prohibitionist eye and overall discomfort. “Fragrance—a blanket term for anything that hyperkinetic syndrome scent to a product—should glucinium avoided,” she explains. “Many of these fragrances can Be irritating and allergenic.”
Your Questions, Answered
What be the best fashion to remove eye makeup?
To avoid aggravating the tegument and to protect the eyes, Dr. Hilal-Campo recommends using visible radiation pressure to push the ware steadfastly against the eye (while your oculus be closed). “Waiting a few minutes will allow the oils in the makeup remover to break down the makeup,” she says. “Then, gently rub IT away from your eyes and repeat As essential until all make-up has be to the full removed.”
Which eye make-up removers are best for sensitive skin?
Those with medium skin and eyes may need to Be Thomas More careful about the formulas they choose. You’ll neediness to look for expression chock-full of skin-conditioning ingredients like glycerin and hyaluronic acid piece avoiding irritant like alcohol, fragrances, and sulfates. You may also neediness to avoid makeup rub if you have ultrasensitive skin arsenic the rubbing might Be aggravating.
What can I do if I get eye war paint remover in my eyes?
Whenever you’re experiencing eye botheration from getting something in your eye, whether it be eye war paint remover Beaver State A stray eyelash, the technique be always the same. “Use angstrom unfertile collyrium solution—you tin can steal some at the drugstore—to bloom out your eye,” Dr. Hilal-Campo explains. “Use Sir Thomas More than you think you demand to insure the wrongdoer be fully redden out.” If you’re still experience some redness and inflammation, angstrom cool compress can help relieve any tarriance discomfort. Of course, if the discomfort still persists, you should see your eye doctor, she says.
Why Shop With Us
Caitlyn Martyn is a former writer for, where she cover skin care, makeup, hair, and fashion. With expert insight from cosmetic chemist Julie Pefferman, ophthalmologist Dr. Diane Hilal-Campo, M.D., aesthetician Kristin Gunn, and tester firsthand experience, she poured over product specifications and rounded up our top pick for this story. Caitlyn has experience researching, testing and composition astir beauty products and has tried tons of different eye makeup removers, including several from the above brands, including wino Elephant, Neutrogena, and Caudalie.
